Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld

United States Supreme Court decision

mba/obodo	Njikota Obodo Amerika
Nwe ikike	Njikota Obodo Amerika
afọ/ụbọchị mbipụta	19 Maachị 1975
ihe omume dị ịrịba ama	oral argument, decision
legal citation of this text	420 U.S. 636, 95 S. Ct. 1225, 43 L. Ed. 2d 514, 1975 U.S. LEXIS 48
court	Supreme Court of the United States
majority opinion by	William J. Brennan
ebipụtara na	United States Reports

Bold text'''Weinberger v. W'Bold text''''Bold text'Bold text''''iesenfeld, 420 U.S. 636 (afọ 1975), bụ mkpebi nke Ụlọikpe Kasị Elu nke United States, nke ji otu olu kwuo na ọdịiche dị n'etiti nwoke na nwanyị n'okpuru 42 U.S.C. ) nke Social Security Act nke afọ 1935 - nke nyere ndị inyom di ha nwụrụ ohere ma ọ bụghị ndị di ha nwụrụ ịnakọta uru pụrụ iche mgbe ha na-elekọta obere ụmụaka - megidere ikike nke nchebe nhata nke Usoro Kwesịrị Ekwesị nke Ndezigharị nke Iwu United States.

Ndabere

Stephen Wiesenfeld na Paula Polatschek lụrụ nà 1970. Stephen na-azụ ahịa ndụmọdụ obere kọmputa ma nwee ego na-adịghị mma. Paula kụziri mgbakọ na mwepụ na Edison High School ma nweta ọtụtụ ihe karịa di ya. Ógè Paula nwụrụ mgbe ọ na-amụ nwa site na amniotic embolism, Stephen ghọrọ naanị onye na-elekọta nwa ha nwoke a mụrụ ọhụrụ, Jason.: 4–6 Iji lekọta nwa ya nwoke, Stephen belatara oge ọrụ ya ma chọọ nlekọta ụmụaka. Wiesenfeld zọrọ erughị eru ya maka uru ndị lanarịrị Social Security nke e nyere ndị inyom di ha nwụrụ, mana ọ bụghị ndị di ha nwụrụ. Caspar Weinberger, odeakwụkwọ nke Ahụike, Mmụta, na Ọdịmma (afọ 1973 rụo 75), gbara akwụkwọ n'ụlọ ikpe Kasị Elu.

Prọfesọ Rutgers Law School Ruth Bader Ginsburg, ya na Melvin Wulf, weere Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld mgbe ọtụtụ mkpebi Ụlọikpe Kasị Elu na-adịghị mma banyere ikpe ịkpa ókè nwoke na nwanyị. N'ime afọ 1974, Kahn v. Shevin kwalitere ọdịiche dị na ụtụ isi ihe onwunwe n'etiti ụmụ nwanyị di ha nwụrụ na ndị di ha nwụrụ, Ụlọikpe Kasị Elu kpebiri na Geduldig v. Aiello na ịgọnahụ nkwụghachi ụgwọ site na ọnwụ ọrụ n'ihi afọ ime emegideghị Ndezigharị nke iri na anọ. Ginsburg lere anya na Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld iji kwalite echiche nke "nlekọta nke nne na nna abụọ na-ahụ n'anya, kama naanị otu."

Ginsburg kwuru na Nkebi nke 402(g) nke Social Security Act na-akpa ókè megide Stephen Wiesenfeld site n'enyeghị ya otu uru ndị lanarịrị dị ka ọ ga-enye nwanyị di ya nwụrụ. Ịga n'ihu,,Ginsburg rụrụ ụka na a naghị emeso onyinye Paula na Social Security n'otu aka ahụ na ụmụ nwoke na-akwụ ụgwọ, ya mere a na-akpa ókè megide ya.

Mkpebi

Ndị ọka ikpe asatọ niile nọ ọdụ kwadoro Wiesenfeld, ebe ọka ikpe Douglas anọghị ọdụ n'ihi ọrịa jị ya. Ha kwupụtara na Nkebi nke 402(g) nke Social Security Act megidere iwu n'ihi na ọdịiche dị n'etiti nwoke na nwanyị megidere Usoro Kwesịrị Ekwesị nke Ndezigharị nke Ise.

Mmepe ndị sochirinụ

Wiesenfeld n'onwe ya amataghi uru ego ọbụna n'ime mkpebi ahụ. Ka ọ na-erule oge ọ malitere ikpe ahụ, ọ mechiri azụmahịa ndụmọdụ ya ma nweta ọkwa a na-akwụ ụgwọ nke ọma na ụlọ ọrụ kọmputa. N'ihi ya, ụgwọ ọrụ ya karịrị nkwụsị ego maka ịnata uru Social Security: 10 

Leekwa

• Ịha nhata nwoke na nwanyị
• Ndepụta nke ikpe nhata nwoke na nwanyị
• Califano v. Goldfarb (1977)
• Geduldig v. Aiello (1974)

Edensibia

• Mayeri, Serena (2011). Echiche Site n'agbụrụ. Harvard University Press.

Ịgụgụ ọzọ

• Ahern (1975). "Economic Discrimination—Denial of Social Security Benefits Premised on Gender-Based Classifications Is Unconstitutional—Violates Equal Protection—Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld". Akron Law Review 9 (1): 166. ISSN 0002-371X. 
• Huaco (1974). "Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld: Equal Protection and Sex Classifications in Government Benefit Programs". New Mexico Law Review 5: 335. ISSN 0028-6214. 

Njikọ mpụga

• Text of Weinberger v. Wiesenfeld, 420 U.S. 636 (1975) is available from: CourtListener  Findlaw  Google Scholar  Justia  Library of Congress  Oyez (oral argument audio)